Arts teachers are assessing learning, transforming practice, and promoting achievement in visual arts, dance, theater, and music.

  • This site represents the work of over 200 New York City arts educators who participated in Artful Learning Communities – our professional learning com­munities engaged in action research, fo­cused on formative as­sess­ment techniques in the arts.

  • Our Mission. Arts Assessment for Learning is committed to K–12 arts education that is focused on formative assessment as a catalyst for student learning. Unlike sum­ma­tive assessment, formative assessment goes beyond simply measuring student achieve­ment. Formative assessment fa­cil­itates teaching and learning by providing useful feedback to both teachers and students. It can increase teacher effectiveness, boost student achievement and motivation, and encourage student independence in the learning process.

    In an educational world too often focused on summative assessment and testing, Arts Assessment for Learning supports teacher practice and student learning by creating a balance between assessment of and assessment for learning.

  • Educators and students alike have come to recognize formative assessment strategies as an integral part of authentic artistic processes. Similar to of the way professional artists work, formative assessment involves students in setting goals, assessing their own work, and making modifications in response to critique, with the teacher guiding the way. Teachers provide clear criteria for success, carefully scaffold students in giving and receiving con­struc­tive feedback, and allow them to choose and make their own revisions. Each of these actions is integral to any creative endeavor involving rehearsal and revision. Thus, formative assessment is an organic process in an arts classroom.

    Arts Assessment for Learning is committed to building communities of arts educators, and engaging them in implementing and analyzing the effectiveness of formative assessment in their classrooms. Our website is designed to share the results of the teachers’ action research as well as their tools and strategies.

Formative Assessment
in action:

Through an ongoing process involving clear criteria, feedback, and revision, students learn to work and think like artists. Teachers lead them to ask three questions:

  • 1. Where am I going?

    Students are given, or in some cases create, clear criteria. This enables them to visualize success.

  • 2. Where am I now?

    As they work, students receive timely, structured feedback from teachers, peers, and reflection on their own work.

  • 3. How do I get there from here?

    Students decide whether and how to respond to feedback. Through revisions to their work, they deepen their learning and improve their performance.

  • Formative assessment is naturally suited to teaching and learning in the arts… its practice aligns closely to the creative process and fosters each student’s artistic voice.

  • An Artful Process. Formative assessment engages educators and students together in what teachers in Arts Assessment for Learn­ing have come to recognize as authentic artistic processes. In its im­ple­men­tation, stu­dents set goals, assess their own work, and determine and make mod­ifi­cations in re­sponse to critique, with the teacher guiding the way. Teachers provide clear criteria for success, engage students in giving and receiving feedback, and allow them to choose and make their own re­vi­sions. Each of these actions is integral to any creative endeavor involving rehearsal and re­vi­sion. Thus, formative assessment is naturally suited to teaching and learning in the arts.

  • Voices Raised. Students involved in a formative assessment process take more ownership of their art making; and as a result, they develop more than just content-knowledge and skill sets. Their plans are their own making, their decisions belong to them, and their reflections on their work emerge through responses to critique, with their teacher guiding the way. Formative assessment is best practice in any class­room, but because it builds confidence in one’s own choices, expressions, and ar­tic­ula­tions, it is especially powerful in teaching in the arts. Formative assessment emulates the creative process and fosters every student’s artistic voice.